Blog Archive

Wednesday, August 18, 2021

Book Review

His Dark Materials trilogy: The Golden Compass, The Subtle Knife, The Amber Spyglass, by Phillip Pullman 

If I had a dollar for every time the Christian "establishment" has declared something in pop culture to be of or from the devil, from Elvis Presley to Harry Potter, I'd be rich. And I don't mean that derisively. Anything of mass popularity has the potential to draw people from God so, in a generalized way, almost everything is of the devil. That's why I've never joined in with group-think even within the social communities that I belong to and identify with because more times than not, the group-think messaging ends up being ill informed panic spreading. However, in the case of these books, they actually got it right. They are almost literally of the devil. The atheist's answer to Narnia, God is merely a sentient and malevolent scientific phenomenon and, in a bid to have it both ways, the way to defeat this authority hinges on the writer's misguided idea of original sin as being the virtue that must be repeated in order to save the world(s). (There's so much misguided ignorance and a perpetuation of every depressing notion that caters to people who want to believe in the evils of Christianity.) Yes, it's as weird as it sounds. That's all the detail I'll go into about it though. I'd rather not dive into philosophical discussions unless it's with others who have read the books since there's some denominational specificity to the underlying narrative. 
I'm not even sure of how much popularity it actually had. I'd never heard of it until they adapted the first book, The Golden Compass, and the controversy may have thrown more attention on it than what it generated on its own. It's just such a shame because after reading them, I found that I genuinely couldn't help but like these books. They are so well written with creative scifi/fantasy world building elements that have little or nothing to do with the religious, or rather, anti religious overtones. There's a multiverse and a specially made knife that enables people to travel between alternate worlds. One world is our own, but the main world is Lyra's steampunk world in which people's souls are physically represented by animals that they have to keep safe with them, as well as talking bears and witches when more magic is needed than science. Then there's another that is peopled only with societies of intelligent, non Terran like beasts that have very different skeletal structures and means of mobility. So there's a lot of imaginative variety. The characters are three dimensional and are easy to become fully and quickly invested in. They grow, mature, and even change alignments. Even if the growth seems to be in the wrong direction from a believer's perspective, the point is that they're not written stagnantly as vapid vehicles to push the religion of atheism. The tensions and motivations aren't saturated with the agenda either. Pullman is so blunt and honest about his beliefs that he doesn't need to keep beating away at them with endless hints, allegory, and preachy dialog. 
Of course all of this adds to the temptation to see it as the right way to believe. Devilishly clever? 😂 It's a kid's series but I would absolutely not recommend it be shown to any children unless you're an atheist who wants to hand down your faith to your child. I can't deny though that I recommend it to adult lovers of science fiction and fantasy who are secure enough in whatever their beliefs are to remain disconnected from the sad affront to religion, especially Christianity. Isn't it strange that Christianity is the only religion that offends so deeply that people feel compelled to attack it so vehemently? That only solidifies my belief in it even more strongly.

Monday, June 28, 2021

Book Review

The Desolation of Devil's Acre, Ransom Riggs 

A fitting end to an entertaining sextet of books. The first trilogy ended so well that the second trilogy wasn't even needed, but it ended up enhancing the original idea and then bringing it full circle to where it started. It demonstrated as it unpacked the world that had been built in the first series that there only a limited way in which the characters could realistically exist within. But it's not a let down or a commentary on any lack of talent on the part of the author. It was an exploration of the material, stretching of it slightly, but not breaking it. Not casting aside what works in attempt to improve it. It was a successful exercise in depth and enrichment. I only would have liked to have seen a little follow up at the end. After the reset the two main characters could definitely have lived, at least partially, as normals and there were others that could have too. I think an epilogue of how some of their lives proceeded would have given a better sense of closure since it's clear that no more, or very little more, can be done with this concept. 
It had some flaws. It had a couple of holes left unplugged; teasers that was went nowhere. In particular, the insinuation that those seeking revenge on Jacob's grandfather may have had valid reasons for doing so. But it's a thread that was lost in the creation of tensions between the American and European peculiars. Also, the movement of dissenters in the Acre against the ymbryns didn't cause as many problems as it was positioned to. But that's probably for the best. It could have gotten too complicated. 
On the whole it was a neat little series of books. I don't know if I have a favorite since they all run together so closely. I guess my favorite part will always be the photographs. They give the story an extra dimension and were what I'd always looked forward to when buying the next book. This last book has an abundance of them in it. Probably as many as the first book of the first trilogy, so I was pleased at that since the other books had been slightly lacking. It's not for everyone but I recommend it to anyone who enjoys creative writing because it still feels like a long experiment of creative writing to me. And I enjoyed it.

Wednesday, June 9, 2021

Book Review


The Conference of the Birds, Ransom Riggs


Such a great little series. I'm always surprised every time I get one that I end up liking it. Riggs really made a creative and unique world in a genre that has seen it all. He's a talented story teller and knows how to keep the reader's attention and the pages turning. All of the books lead into directly into the sequels with no break in the action, even when transitioning from the first to the second trilogy. I'm glad the movie that was made a few years back opted not to follow the book series. It would be hard to keep up the pace that makes them such an interesting read. Also, the old photos within are such a big part of the descriptions and its hard to translate that into film.
There wasn't much to say about the plot of A Map of Days since the transitioning from England to America and a broader examination of how the paculiar world is governed ate up the bulk of the text. But towards the end it began the overarching story in earnest with the mention of a prophecy (and who doesn't love a good prophecy in fantasy?) along with introducing one of the characters that the prophecy is centered around. Jacob wants to follow in his grandfather's footsteps of being a protector of persecuted paculiars and gets to start doing it even sooner than he thinks. Certainly sooner than he's ready to, even with his experience of guiding Miss Peregrine's peculiars around WWII London under his belt. Many mistakes are made along with some progress. Being the middle of the series it has to end on a downer. But even as they're walking into what is obviously a trap at the end, it's not the type of trap I initially expected. Riggs is very masterful at cliffhangers.
It also gives me a greater appreciation for the first person pov. Third person limited is still my favorite, but when the teenage protagonist makes the inevitable bone head mistakes, this story does a better job than most of conveying his reasoning and is more honest about his naivity. After all, these five books all take place over the course of a few months without any time for him to digest all that's happened or to let the lessons learned settle in and become more guarded. Rushing from ond dire circumstance to the next. Even during the lag in action at the beginning of the last book, he was still getting new information about his grandfather's life in America to process. Not getting all of it at once, naturally, it keeps him moving from one stressful thing to think about to another so that the pacing never slowed down even while time was devoted to setting up the new background for this trilogy.
There's still an element of predictability that all the books have. And there's still some sneering at America in this one, but it's very low key and only visible to the trained mind. But it's just a good fun story which I still recommend and I had to buy the final book without waiting until next Christmas. 

Saturday, May 29, 2021

Book Review retcon

I got the sequel to this one over Christmas but it's been a couple of years so a re-read was in order. It's the first of a second trilogy in the Peculiar series. I remember being kind of hard on this book when I first read it. I was still reeling from the emotional rollercoaster ride of the series I'd finished prior to reading it, so it just wasn't sitting right with me. It's crazy how books can effect you like that.. 😄. But after reading it again I can see how well planned it was this time around. There are still a couple of tedious moments of America bashing for a plot point. (A plot point with holes because sometimes it's more important to prove you're cool by being lazy than to make sense... so tiresome...) But overall it's not the copy of other hidden world fantasies that I remember it being. It's not over dramatic...  that was my own emotional state, lol. And and all of the elements that built up to the end were not as slow as I recalled either. The world needed to be tweaked, reconstructed and expanded in more detail in order to move forward from the original premise. I'd also completely forgotten the ending so I would've been lost if I'd just started the sequel. 
Lesson here: there's always an advantage to re-reading.

Wednesday, May 19, 2021

Book Review

The Man In The Iron Mask, Alexander Dumas

Disappointing, but probably not in the way most people would be disappointed. I get it, that this is the swan song of the Musketeers. I wasn't even bothered by Porthos and Athos deaths. Porthos' death was actually pretty magnificent and heroic and just how one would expect it. Athos' was very sad and tragic, but it made sense. But D'Artagnan's death just seemed mean on the part of Dumas. Why do him that way? He's the protagonist and the only one with any sense. I actually expected all of them to die so I was even a little disappointed that Aramis lived.
But what bothers me about this is what bothered me about The Three Musketeers. I don't understand how the respect is won by the characters who were clearly the antagonists throughout the book. Richelieu in the Musketeers, and the king and Colbert in particular in this one. I chalked it up to my ignorance of French history since the narrative is tangled with real historical figures like the royalty. But twice in a row? Maybe it's just that the characters are all too damned honorable for their own good. Especially Fouqet.
Then there's the matter of loose ends. No follow up on Phillipe, who was pushed into the coup to begin with. I felt bad for him and he becomes a throwaway character after the first almost third of the book is devoted to becoming invested in him and his life story. And we never find out Madame de la Valliere's reasons for becoming the royal consort when she loved Raoul. Reasons that would have made her a more sympathic figure presumably. Or maybe I was expecting something that Dumas never intended to give. Rather that she was predicting that she would fall out of favor one day and that's why she'd be pitied. I don't know. 
Anyway, what a bummer. I'll just stick with the first book. At least it was fun even when it didn't make sense. The writing is spectacular though. Hard to put down. Loved the old characters while they lasted.

Saturday, March 27, 2021

Book Review

Wuthering Heights, Emily Brontë
One of my knee jerk reactions to this one is, Oh my goodness, everyone in this book has serious mental problems...lol. I think on the whole I liked Jane Eyre better, but that's not to say I didn't like this at all. It's a revenge tale after all, and I love revenge. 
I think it would have been a more satisfying revenge if Heathcliff's beloved Catherine was around to see the damage he inflicted on all her remaining family. I think I just didn't see the driving obsession after she was gone. I would've liked to have seen his descent into madness more closely documented but it wasn't possible with the pov used. I did enjoy the pov though. What a creative way to tell the story. Not just second, but third hand. All juicy gossip. Very clever. Ellen Dean was the observer character and the only one with any common sense. If I was her I'd have washed my hands of the whole family after the patriarch died. But if she had we wouldn't have the story. She and all the other characters seemed to suffer from a obstinate kind of tunnel vision that kept them set on their paths for years. It left little room for growth with the exception of Hareton and Catherine the younger. Consequently, Heathcliff's sudden disinterest in torturing everyone around him came as a surprise. It all had to do with his mind deteriorating from his madness and hallucinations of his Catherine and I was very interested in seeing this fleshed out. But from a second hand account all that can be conveyed is a mysterious tease. 
Still I don't have many complaints. The classics are still the best and this should be on everyone's classic reading list. If I had to rate it, I'd do 4 of 5 stars.

Thursday, February 18, 2021

Book Review


The ABC Murders, Agatha Christie

*Kind of a big spoiler warning. I try to avoid them but I couldn't this time. *
I really loved this little mystery. The classics are still the best for mystery. I haven't read a lot of Poirot yet. In fact the only other one I have read was Orient Express in which he was traveling alone. So I didn't realize the similarities it shared with the Sherlock Holmes formula. He had his own "Watson" in the form of Captain Hastings and a relationship with local law enforcement like the the great Holmes. But these Poirot novels are unique and and different enough that they aren't really a rip off of Doyle. This one even takes a friendly jab at the Holmesian style of crime solving. It smirks at the standard clue hunting and takes a more psychological approach.
The perpetrator in this book, as indicated in the title, commits his murders alphabetically, not just by name but by town as well. Obviously. And a really creepy guy with a name to match the crimes is likely responsible. So obvious. Too obvious. And I fell for it hook, line, and sinker. I'm usually better at solving the mystery than that.  In fact, a remark made by Hastings at a pivotal part of the story that touched off Poirot's final deduction was my first thought as well, so my instincts were correct. But then it took a twist I never suspected. I think now that I should have expected it considering the unconventional ending of Orient Express. Being longer than most Holmes mysteries the pace can be slower and the misdirection can come from every character. Not everything Poirot notes is necessarily significant. It's a good trick.
And I'll keep it in mind because I do believe I'm hooked on the Poirot specific novels. I'll be checking more out and if anyone who has read more of them has any suggestions, I can't wait to hear them.