Blog Archive

Friday, January 31, 2020

Book Review


The Autobiography of Thomas Jefferson

It's short and incomplete, but I was aware of that when I bought it. I don't think Jefferson was much interested in putting down his life's works for posterity. Perhaps if he'd started this memoir before the age of 77 he may have gotten more written. That's not to say I'm disappointed in any way though. I chose this edition instead of a biography because I simply don't trust authors to write about the founding fathers, Jefferson in particular, without heavy bias against them. Although I admit the biography I have of James Madison by Ralph Ketchum is pretty good. 

The cons include, as previously stated, that it's evident that Jefferson didn't care to write about himself. So there aren't a lot of details about his childhood and young life. He mentions where he was born, what his father did for a living, the schools he attended, and his marriage with no more sentimentality than one would place in bullet points. However, when he does offer a personal opinion of a mentor or a fellow statesman as well as his notation of the death of his wife, you get a great teaser of what his personality must have been like and makes me wish he'd taken the time to offer a more passionate description of events. Annoyingly, his most animated writing is reserved for his time spent in France. As a Gallophile, he goes into great detail about the early days of France's revolution, his opinion of how he would've acted to prevent the downward turn it took, and his desire to go back and witness it in real time as it was going on. He spends so much time on this that he doesn't even make it to his own presidency or even vice presidency and just gives a brief mention of accepting the role of Washington's Secretary of State.

But the pros outweigh all of this. It's kind of like seeing a diary of our Revolution as it was happening from the viewpoint of the congress as opposed to the battlefield which is certainly different. He offers the unedited edition of the Declaration of Independence in this small volume with the parts stricken out and the parts added in shown in different typefaces. You see a lot of the same arguments that were laid out in the Federalist Papers for how the new government is to be set up with opposing arguments stated by other people in the discussions he had during different sessions. It's fascinating to read about the debate and thought process that went into a monetary system or a redesign of the prison system... things you don't usually think about when speaking of our Revolutionary War. 

I do recommend it but I also think the best way to research Jefferson further is to look into all of his correspondences, many of which have been saved. Not just his personal correspondence with John Adams, but other letters to other people of note in that time. There's a volume out there that has all of these and I may look into it sometime.

Monday, January 20, 2020

Book Review

Jane Eyre, by Charlotte Brontë
Happily surprised with how much I like this book. I think I even love it. A kind of: where has it been all my life? moment. Of course it's been there the whole time I'm just finicky and procrastination-prone when it comes to picking books.

I'm not as chained to my usual genre preferences when it comes to classic fiction; it's a genre of its own. When reading the classic ladies' novels they're often romances and I'm never sure what I'll get. I adored Little Women and while I liked the Jane Austin novels I tried, they lacked some of the "wow" factor. That's probably why I waited so long to try another classic piece. And I think I see now what makes a classic romance appealing to me... when there's a lot more going on than just the romance. It's the defining portion of this novel too, but the protagonist has many other experiences that shape and define her. The book is about Jane Eyre not just Jane Eyre finding love after a relatively love-starved existence. Her journey of growth before meeting Mr. Rochester is its own story and the journey of faith she takes after she leaves Thornfield Hall is yet another. I didn't read the preface thoroughly so I was still able to enjoy some surprises, although most classic fiction is predictable to a certain degree.

Of course modern society teaches disdain for stories like this... I've seen the "describe a classic badly " jokes - examples: a young governess falls in love with a charming asshole edge lord who keeps his wife in the attic - a comic portraying Rochester complaining about how he's suffered terribly from spending his wife's fortune to sleep his way around Europe, etc. There's a kernal of truth that makes them funny. But the psychology of the characters is actually pretty accurate and the romance is a common fantasy women whether they admit it or not. The woman's innocence and gentle goodness changes the man's hardened, scoundrel nature. There's even instances of unrequited love in there as well which is the kind of love story I like. It's also a wonderful reminder of how marriage should not entered into lightly whether it's a marriage of love, of convenience, or arranged. Not something taken very seriously nowadays.

The pacing is a little slow but when it moves it takes you with it. I loved it and recommend it to anyone who likes classics and romance and just a good story. And don't read the forward if you've not read it before.