Blog Archive

Monday, March 20, 2017

Star Trek TNG Allegiance

Fun, tense, and creative episode.  Classic inspiration and fixing of old boondoggles. It's an episode I always love to watch.
And this is one of the many reasons the ladies like Picard... he falls asleep reading at the beginning of the show!  *love sighs*  But unfortunately he gets probed and kidnapped and replaced with a duplicate.
It all happens so fast that by the time they detect a strange energy surge in his quarters and send Worf up there to check it out, Picard greets him at the door and it seems as though it's all been a mistake.
This episode has been compared to an episode of The Twilight Zone called Five Characters In Search Of An Exit, in which an army major wakes up trapped with four others in a cylinder.  They work together to escape only to realize they are figurines in a little girl's toy barrel.  Not the first time Twilight Zone was drawn on for inspiration.  Picard is whisked away to a locked room which at first only contains two others with another to arrive later.  This episode is a reworking of the concept behind Where Silence Has Lease in the second season, which I had a lot of problems with.  In that episode the Enterprise was being experimented on like lab rats by an alien presence, but it was beyond the scope of believeability and included a lot of whining and melodrama.  This episode takes a more focused approach to the concept.  Only one character, Picard, is snatched up for specific behavioral experiments in a laboratory situation.  The experimenting is definitely more controlled and conducted more scientifically compared to that ridiculous face in space that was just a tool to complain about the inferiority of humanity.
It also fixes yet another mistake made in one of my most often complained about episodes from the first season, Lonely Among Us, in which Picard is possessed by an alien force and begins to behave strangely.  In that episode he was creepy from the word go, and even goes as far as admitting that he's an alien being while everyone just worries and waits it out without any attempt to rescue Picard or themselves.  In this episode, the doppelganger Picard doesn't go out of the way to act abnormally at first.  He gives orders to change course, which nobody considers to be a big deal.  What's unusual is that he starts to explore what everyone's reaction is to his actions as he goes on.
Anyway, after all of the subjects are present in the locked room, they soon discover that the most violent and dangerous person can't eat the food stuff that is provided to them so they have to open the door somehow.  The first person that Picard talked to, a Mizarian named Kova Tholl, had been there the longest and knew that there would be a punishing ray that would discharge if any attempt was made to open the door so he doesn't cooperate at first.
Slowly but methodically over the course of the episode, Picard works out what they all have in common - they all respond differently to authority.  The violent Esoqq, being an anarchist, believing in no authority; Tholl, a pacifist, yielding to all authority; a Starfleet cadet, Haro, bound to obey authority, and Picard, a Starfleet captain, the embodiment of authority. It's a smart and fun bit of puzzle solving.

The ingenuity of the writing is that the same experiment is taking place in both places with the Picard double crossing the authoritative boundaries that the real Picard would normally not overstep, both professionally and personally.  This is the only time he interrupts the poker game until the series finale and he looks and feels out of place to everyone, coming to personally ask for system improvements from Geordi.  He has a date with Beverly and now we see a more realistic portrait of their relationship.  From the idiotic and baseless flirtation in the first season, to mature people who have an attraction to each other, but also a past which had rendered them just friends making this sudden interest on Picard's part strange and unseemly.  Once again as in Lonely Among Us, it's awkward and a little creepy, but not too much.
In Lonely Among Us, they wait until it's almost too late to take action with a knowingly compromised Picard.  In this episode, they suspect that something may have happened with that unexplained energy surge, but there's not enough evidence of any kind to support the theory that something is wrong with him.  They have to seriously weigh the options of a potential charge of  mutiny that would result from relieving him of command if they were wrong.  This isn't whining and melodrama.  They've found themselves in a genuine pickle this time, so all they could do is watch and wait at this point.

The imposter Picard finally goes too far when he engages Ten Forward in a round of drinks and singing of an old battle song.  This is so funny and uncomfortable all at once.  Kudos to the creative team. It's truly an epic moment. It's still not enough to relieve Picard of duty, but now the crew are all on the same page when the time comes. The phony Picard starts to endanger the lives of everyone by ordering the ship to be flown too close to a pulsar star.  It seems like a malevolent act, but it's presumably another test of the crew's reactions.  Even Worf abandons his loyalty to Picard for this folly.
Back in the locked room they discover when the four of them work together, they can open the door successfully... only to find another door. Of course, being a Picard episode, his brilliance is on display as he finally figures out that this is a lab experiment.  I personally like the way the writers proceed as though the other episodes just never happened.  They rework them and improve upon them and it's like a redo; a reset.
He cleverly leads the Starfleet cadet into talking about a classified mission that a low ranking cadet wouldn't know about.  He announces to everyone that they're being studied and that Haro is the one observing them and then formally refuses to cooperate anymore.  Once the jig is up Haro transforms into her real form and two others of this race of aliens appear to tell them that all of them that had been taken had their duplicates left in their places.  Picard is outraged but proud to know that his crew had figured out the deception as well and that Riker had already assumed command of the ship.  Since the experiment is a bust, they each grab a hostage and return them to where they came from.
Naturally, the only person who is followed up on is Picard, which makes for another fist-pumping, gotcha ending that was almost as much fun as the ending of Ensigns Of Command so I'll just paste it in here. No philosophical ranting.  No conceding the inferiority of humanity to anyone just because they had the ability to gain the advantage over them.  It's only a little sloppy with the quickness and simplicity of the aliens being unable to bear captivity as a point of irony, but it's easily forgiveable.  It not only displays how cool Picard is *again* but we get to see the crew's precision teamwork on display again and that's always cool as well.

 It doesn't quite have the depth and personal connection for five stars but I have no complaints about it and it's one of my favorites.  Four stars


.






Friday, March 17, 2017

Star Trek TNG Sins Of The Father

Here we go!  The first step in a long and layered development of Klingon culture.

Worf's brother is introduced, but we don't know that at first.  He's just being an exchange officer as Riker was in the second season.  Kurn is serving in a first officer role on the Enterprise and he brings that touch of savage Klingon discipline to the pampered Enterprise crew.  I appreciate the fact that the crew isn't a bunch of whiny babies anymore.  Although there's some complaint about how harsh and demanding he is, Picard allows him to behave exactly as if he were on a Klingon vessel since the point of the exchange is to learn from other cultures.  In one way, I think this episode could've been divided into two parts because they packed so much into it after the main plot is revealed.  On the other hand I feel like too much time was wasted with the preliminaries. Bringing up Riker's service on the Pagh was redundant.  And we all know Klingons are kind of like Vikings now.  We get it.  but I guess it's necessity was to show you that the Kurn was hard on everyone except Worf and that this was not considered favoritism towards someone of his race.  This was an insult.  Worf wanted to be involved in the bully-like command structure common to Klingon warriors.
It doesn't actually take as long as it seems to reach the big reveal.  Kurn explains that he is Worf's younger brother and we find out why they were separated.  Worf had no knowledge of Kurn and Kurn found out about his heritage after he reached the age of ascension although he chose to keep the identity of his adopted father.  And then we get the twist on Khitomer that changes everything.  There was a traitor among the Klingons that enabled the Romulans to lower the Khitomer defence shields and proceed with the massacre.  Worf and Kurn's father is the one accused of committing this treason.  This is not only the seed for Worf's personal struggles throughout the series, but a tangible focal point of the Klingon-Romulan hostilities.  Roddenberry didn't want the Federation to be at war with either of these races anymore because he wanted to move on.  Now we see that there was a huge advantage to have these races at odds with each other.  It was just as much of a challenge for the Federation to be an ally to the Klingons as an enemy and it made for a more challenging sort of story telling.  After determining that Worf hasn't been softened by Federation life, he encourages him to challenge this claim as the older son.

 At first Worf accepts Kurn's offer to be his Cha'Dlch (ritual second) for the process but wisely tells him not to reveal his true bloodline. We see more of the Klingon's devotion to traditions and duties as Worf assumes command of Kurn as his older brother even though he doesn't have any experience on the Klingon home world, and Kurn accepts this dominance albeit with a little grumbling.  This is why I and many others came to love the way Klingons were written.  Loud pigs... perhaps.. but strong and stalwart in honor and tradition.
 We meet K'mpec for the first time.  He's the head of the Klingon High Council and although he only gets two episodes he's one of the most memorable characters.  Another council member, Duras, formally accuses Mogh of treason.  Because Worf is challenging this accusation falls on him as well and if it's proven to be true he will be put to death.  K'mpec asks Worf not to continue with this challenge in a fatherly sort of way and Duras attacks Worf and Kurn in an alley leaving the audience to realize that something is up with all of this.
But Picard steps in as Worf's Cha'Dlch and they persist in trying to fight back against this accusation.  Picard puts the Enterprise on it and of course, they find out that the evidence for Mogh being the traitor was false and that there was another survivor and witness.
The survivor was Worf's nurse.  The scenes in which Picard decides to seek her out and then find her are important in the development of his character as well.  He's not just a diplomat but very brave and daring because he sets out to do this alone.  It also opens the door for him to become prominent in Klingon political affairs later on. The lady, Kahlest, helps him deal with the ambush he walks into and then reluctantly agrees to testify.
Why reluctantly?  Well, that's politics.  Giving this situation an added political layer just made it more complex and opened ended leaving the fans wanting to see justice done.  It's a kind of soap writing - the first victory going to the bad guy so that the good guy could eventually prevail.  This is why Star Trek TNG eventually eclipsed TOS in quality.  K'mpec is forced to admit that they knew that Duras' father was the traitor, but his family was too powerful to punish because it would ruin the Empire.  So the blame was placed on Mogh since they figured that Worf would never come to challenge such a claim since he was a part of the Federation and, of course, they didn't know about Kurn.  Now Worf's only choice would seem to be to die as a traitor in order to save the Empire and it's a sacrifice that he's willing to make.  The problem is Kurn.  Now that everyone knows, Worf wants his life spared but Duras objects since this would give Kurn a legal claim to revenge... making him an even more contemptible coward.
In order for Kurn to keep his anonymity and life, Worf accepts discommendation; banishment; exiled in disgrace.  Essentially admitting that the claim against his father is true.  One by one the council turns their backs on Worf including Kurn out of necessity and it's such an powerful scene.  It's not a happy ending.  It's a complicated ending with more to come. It lights a fire with the audience and with the creative writing element of the show.  This is great stuff.

I give this one four and a half stars because I think it could've gone further and been more detailed.  I might be suffering from expectations that are too high because I became used to the higher quality of episodes to come, but I'm not going to go with five on this one even though there's not much difference in four and a half and five in this case.













Wednesday, March 15, 2017

Book review

Just finished this one today.





The Arabian Nights translated by Husain Haddawy
What strange and entertaining stories... or so Dinarzad would say.
Not for kids. Not even for teenagers. On the one hand as you read through these you can get an idea of why a portion of Middle Eastern culture is so screwed up, especially regarding women. But on the other hand they're fascinating and I found myself wanting to know what would happen next.
The G-rated version of the base story is about a King named Shahrayer who decides to marry a different woman every day and to have her executed the following morning until the daughter of his main governor, Shahrazad, decides that she will stop him by marrying him and telling him stories every night that will leave him so intrigued that he would delay her execution so that he could hear more. The stories she tells are old Arabic fables and fairy tales mainly from the 13th and 14th centuries. I lost track of how many stories there were since they're divided into "nights" (271 in total) and each tale lasts a minimum of three nights with most going on and on for many nights spinning tales within tales. But it's actually not hard to keep a mental thumb in the page and remember the beginning tale that all subsequent tales within eventually lead back to. It's a win for brains over brawn because it impresses upon the readers that storytelling used to be a vital part of society - all societies, as all cultures have fables and fairy tales in their history. In this case and in the case of many of the tales, a good story would be enough to spare the lives of many characters.
I thought the introduction and notes about the translation process was even more interesting than the material within. The translator explains the history of the different translations and how at one point when someone decided that it had to be 1001 nights that all kinds of stories from varying cultures were added in that didn't belong to the original collection such as Aladdin and The Magic Lamp. He also specifies how and why original texts were changed to suit the different audiences and from what I understand this is the most accurate translation you can find if you're interested. From an academic standpoint it's fascinating, but like I said, keep kids away from it... they're immature sensibilities probably won't be able to handle all of the bawdy and childish nonsense that takes place in the stories.
Of course, since the base story of Shahrayar and Shahrazad is just a vehicle to hold the old fables, their story is never finished other than to say that tradition holds that the king learns to trust women again and they live happily ever after, essentially. The stories are also said not to be set down in any particular order, but I think I could see a pattern that seemed to fit in with Shahrazad's plan in that as the tales progressed the women became less wanton and treacherous and the king not only stopped planning to put her to death after he heard the end of a tale, but eventually just started asking for the next one after one was definitely finished. This would seem to confirm that this is the best translation. I can't say it's the greatest book I've ever read, but it was a curiosity that was well worth the time to pursue.

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

Cheat codes

I saw Pixels for the first time the other night and I was really enjoying all of the video game nostalgia.  I was so distracted by the concept that I was actually surprised by the plot twist that Eddie used cheat codes for the Pac Man sequence.

First of all, I didn't realize the oldest games like Pac Man and others on display in this movie had cheat codes. But I'm not surprised.  In the movie, Eddie uses the cheat codes to win at an official competition in 1982 and again in the war with these Pixel aliens, making his win illegitimate.  I suppose if you're in an official competition or war with video game aliens, then cheating would be a bad thing, but I never thought of cheat codes as cheating.

This video demonstrates one of at least three glitches in Super Mario World for SNES that enabled a person to get 99 lives.  It's not the one I personally used.  I went into a different level and flew over all of the enemies until I got to a point where I found a point button that, when pressed, would turn all of the enemies into 3 lives-up coins and go through the level a couple of times.  But these glitches were purposeful.  In Super Mario World they had a section where you could go in and pick up a free Yoshi and cape without being bothered by any enemies, so it makes sense that they'd hide other helpful Easter eggs throughout the game if you spend enough time exploring and trying different things.  There wasn't much else you could do to cheat in Mario, but this was a great little glitch for people like me who aren't good players and died a lot.

Unless you had a Game Genie and there was one for all of the different consoles at one point.  This would give you options for making winning the levels of the game easier as the later DOS game cheat codes would do.


Fast forward to the old DOS games for the PC.  Duke Nukem, Doom, Wolf 3D, Blood, Redneck Rampage.  They all had cheat codes to enter on the keyboard that would do a variety of things, some of which are demonstrated in this video.  I've met people that think that this is the stupidest thing - why bother playing after all?  But the thing is, most people wouldn't use every single cheat available.  I never used the ones to show me the map or to have all of the keys because solving the puzzle was the fun part for me.  I liked blowing away the monsters but I didn't want to be hindered from solving the puzzle by dying every couple minutes, so I always used "God Mode" and a cheat that would give me all of the available weapons.  Because, lets face it, the weapons were all very cool and you didn't get a lot of opportunity to use them all and not for very long depending on how much ammo they carried.  It was more of a way of customizing your gaming experience than a way of actually cheating.

And you couldn't always use them.  In the difficulty settings, if you chose the hardest setting, you weren't allowed to use cheats at all typically.  I guess the thinking behind that is if you're good enough for that setting, you don't need to cheat.  Or perhaps because you're that good you wouldn't want the cheat.  The thing about "cheats" is that they weren't always there to make things easy.  I can't find examples on the internet, but almost all of these game had a code that would start you in a level with only half of your health or ammo.  You could enter these codes if you wanted more of a challenge.  I wouldn't call giving yourself a disadvantage deliberately cheating, would you?

Being open source, a lot of them had silly patches to use too. Patches that would turn all of the monsters in to Barney.  Or make your heroes Beavis and Butthead.  I think Duke 3D had a nudity patch.  Silly things like this to customize and play with.  Those were the good old days.


Anyway, I miss cheat codes.  Playing until a feature is "unlocked" isn't quite the same.  I don't have the skill to play games like Call Of Duty which look like a lot of fun, but without a little edge, I'm stuck with the Fable series.  It's not a bad series and I love it to pieces.  But the gaming world has kind of passed me by since the old cheat codes have gone out of  fashion.  Sill fun to reminisce about.

Monday, March 13, 2017

Star Trek TNG The Offspring

I'm not like most women who get all teary-eyed at every emotional episode, but I don't need to be an emotionally heightened person to know this one is a tear-jerker.

The plot is very simple. Data comes back from a cybernetics conference and creates another Soognian type of android based on his own specs.  He invites Troi, Geordi, and Wesley to the first revealing. They're surprised when the new android refers to Data as "father," but really they shouldn't have been since Data had long considered  Dr. Noonien Soong, his creator, to be his father as he thought of Lore as his brother and Dr. Ira Graves (Soong's mentor) as his Grandfather.  Data episodes are always good.  I had complained in the Ira Graves episode that bringing all kinds of "family" out of the woodwork tended to water down Data's uniqueness, especially the fact that Graves could work on him so proficiently when he and Lore are supposed to be the only two functioning androids in the galaxy with the creator dead (at this point.)  But Data attempting to make another android can't be seen in that fashion.
He explains it best when he's defending his actions to the Captain with the argument that all species procreate and this is his way of doing just that.  In the case that he were to be damaged or destroyed, he would have an offspring to carry on this specie of 1 (4 in total - Data, Lore, Lal, and later Soong's ex wife.)  I thought it was a little unfair for the characters to assume that Captain Picard was insensitive to the situation because he wasn't a parent.  I'm not a parent, and I understand.  I'm sure the Captain did too, but since he's the man in charge, he knew how the politics of the Federation were and that their interference was inevitable.
I wasn't really crazy about that part either.  I know they needed some conflict, but this shouldn't have been an issue since Data was officially declared a life form in the best episode of the second season via a trial by the Federation JAG officer.  Admiral Heftel had no business demanding that Lal be handed over for study.  And they did bring this point up but, as is the case with all government interference, a governing outfit can discard rules whenever they see fit so maybe it's not as unrealistic as all that.

Anyway, this is a great use of the holodeck.  Data allows Lal to choose its gender and appearance.  I think people seeing it now would find it to be trendsetting stuff considering how far off the deep end America has gone socially in the past few years.  But since the androids have no emotional baggage or attachment to any kind of form or sexuality, this is actually logical.  Dr. Soogn was a human who created Data in his own image out of basic vanity.  Data has no such inclination and allows Lal's development to progress more freely.  Lal chooses the form of a human female. And they do a wonderful job of packing the episode with valuable and memorable moments.

Although Lal has all the knowledge that Data has, she still has no social skills or understanding of human behavior.  There are tender moments as Data tries to explain a variety of things.  Beauty, painting, table manners.  You get to see the awkwardness of her trying to socialize with children who are too young and afraid of her to accept her.  Seeing the tendency of children to be cruel explained by Data provides a harsh but accurate viewpoint.  They take you through a lot of things that parents have to deal with.  They even get to a point where she's asking so many questions that Data simply shuts her off for a while... something I'm sure every parent wishes they can do when they get to that age.
Fine tuning her motor skills provides comical moments.

As well as her time spent in Ten Forward.  Data encourages her to work with Guinan to help understand human interaction.  Two in a row for Guinan.  Frakes directed this episode which is why his time is limited to being accosted by a confused Lal who thinks that kissing is normal social interaction for any two people. Hysterical.

It's also where to see the first signs that something has gone wrong.  It doesn't seem wrong at the time... she simply starts using contractions.  Something that Data could never do.  At first it seems like a victory and an extension of Soong's work.  But after being interviewed extensively by the Admiral and Picard and being faced with the possibility of having to leave Data and the Enterprise, things start to go wrong.  She starts to develop emotions.  Fear and confusion.
She's programed to return to Data's laboratory if something is wrong.  Her development of emotions turns out to be a malfunction rather than a miraculous extension of Data's matrix and programming.  The Admiral comes in to help Data try to repair the cascade failure in her brain and is finally moved to compassion for the situation.  Finally seeing them as a father and daughter rather than property but it's too late.
Lal suffers complete neurological failure after professing her love for Data.  It's quite a moment.  You'd have to be heartless not to feel sorry for Data especially because he can't feel sad for himself.  It also alleviates my worries about all of these new family members watering down Data's uniqueness.  This was an attempt to recreate Soong's work that failed and it makes sense in the progression of the series.  Data and Lore could function because Soong did the work himself and nobody - not Admiral Heftel or Commander Maddox, or even Data could duplicate it.  And Graves is just best forgotten.

This was an excellent episode.  The only reason I give it four and a half instead of five is because the narrative of any Soognian android being potential property for the Federation has been hit enough at this point and I found it an irritating source of conflict especially since she was intended to malfunction and "die" anyway.  That was more than enough by itself along with the sweet story of emotionless Data raising a daughter.









Friday, March 10, 2017

Star Trek TNG Yesterday's Enterprise

The trailer I posted isn't one of the normal ones that ran on T.V. but a special one made by a fan to seem like a movie trailer.  This episode deserves that.  It's one of the best episodes in the series and one of my personal favorites.

It's one of the best uses of time anomalies I've ever seen and the teaser scene, which is a perfectly random portrait of life on the Enterprise and one to make the audience bond even more with Worf, is there to show you what will be missing.  One of the biggest problems with time travel, and understandably so, is that the characters have a conscious knowledge that a time anomaly has taken place.  They'd done something similar to this in the episode Time Squared in the second season.  Except at the end of the episode, they know they've solved the problem when the dopple-Picard  and shuttle disappear.  Like I said, it's understandable because there has to be closure in a story and especially in a series like Star Trek where somebody has to keep track of all the changes in order for the day to be saved.  What this episode does is take a more realistic approach to a change in a timeline.  A strange wormhole appears and suddenly everything changes... and nobody notices.  Suddenly there was never any Worf and all that has transpired for his character. And no Troi because her profession isn't required on a battleship.  But then, there's Tasha, alive again!... but everyone knows it's not right.  It's dark.  It's war.  The loss and gain without a word of dialogue is a breathtaking effect for the audience to enjoy.
I shouldn't say nobody because this is where a character like Guinan comes in handy.  Since her character's race was never explained in detail and always a little enigmatic, she was useful as the person who knew something had changed, but not consciously so that the timeline-change part of the story isn't completely ruined.  It was a smooth way to create a focal point that would help to shift the timeline back to normal.  The writing in this episode is exemplary.

The Federation is still at war with the Klinons and the Captain's Log is now a military Log and they take note of the ship that emerged from the wormhole.  It's the Enterprise C which was the model of the ship that came directly before this Enterprise.  Captain Garrett tries to explain their situation but because their presence caused the timeline to change, the history the Enterprise D crew knows doesn't match up to the story Garrett is giving them about defending Klingons from a surprise Romulan attack.  But the mystery is set aside for the sake of rescuing the crew and repairing the heavy damage they'd taken while Klingon ships are on the way.

So they put Guinan into effect by having her track down Picard to tell him that this isn't right and to set in motion the debate on whether or not to send them back to their own time when their deaths are pretty much guaranteed if they do. They spend a respectable amount of time on that philosophical point, but much of the episode is spent correcting the wrongs done to the character of Tasha Yar.  She's seen doing her job expertly - Helping to update the old Enterprise's weapons and forming battle strategies.  She gets to fall in love... something she didn't have a chance to do since her character left so early on in the series.  It's a fast romance, but not unbelievable because they were in the middle of a war and a lifetime to cultivate a relationship is never a guarantee in such cases.
Although Guinan wasn't in the first season, when Picard first speaks to her in the second season, he speaks to her as if she'd been there the whole time.  For that reason, it's okay to assume that Guinan would know that Tasha's presence is wrong.  She tells her of the vague notions she has that she's supposed to be dead already by a senseless and pointless demonstration of power.  This episode really solidifies Guinan's intuition as being very relevant and valuable.

After plenty of discussion and a revelation that the Federation will probably have to surrender in less than six months, Garrett chooses to go back and try to defend the Klingons from the Romulans that were inserting themselves into the situation back in her time.  It is Data who notes that this could change the outcome of the war since Klingons value honor above all else.  Still developing Klingon culture even when there's not one Klingon in the show... win!!  As they go back to prepare, Captain Garrett is killed and Lt. Castillo, who Tasha has fallen for, is left in charge.

 Her love for Richard and the knowledge of what her alternate fate was had the war not gone on this long propel her brave, warrior nature into transferring over to the Enterprise C in order to help give them an edge when they go back. Since she's supposed to be dead already and since her death if she returns with C is imminent, there would be no temporal repercussions from this decision.
 And then the riveting climax - all is sacrifice.  Enterprise D takes the full brunt of the attack so that Enterprise C can return through the wormhole.  They can't survive, but after Enterprise C returns, so does the original timeline with Worf and Troi int their proper places.  Guinan senses the change again, but knows that everything is back to normal. And more importantly, nobody else remembers anything unusual ever happened at all.  But the audience knows.  They lost Tasha again.  But this time it meant something.  It wasn't just done for shock in an episode about nothing.  She ended up being a pivotal part of the Federation's peace with the Klingons in history.  And although we later find out she survived the battle she went back into, for now we are satisfied with a happy ending and the hero's death that a character like that deserves. It was just brilliant from start to finish.  Five stars all the way.